Sustainability Reports Rapidly Becoming Expected Disclosure

VIEW AS PDF

By Don Carpenter, MSAcc/CPA

Knowledgeable investors are quite accustomed to the standard reporting cycle of public companies, culminating in the Annual Report (Form 10-K) followed closely thereafter by the Proxy Statement. These reports offer insight into the financial viability and corporate governance of organizations. Although not part of the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) disclosure regime, the Sustainability Report is taking its place in what is rapidly becoming a triumvirate of reports that guide investors in their portfolio allocation.

The Sustainability Report is also referred to as the ESG disclosure because material Environmental, Social and Governance matters are reported. As such issues as climate change, fair trade and income inequality have moved to the forefront of business issues, more and more fund managers and individual investors are taking these matters into consideration when making investment decisions. This is reflected in the growing number of companies issuing annual sustainability reports.

A recent survey by the Governance & Accountability Institute, Inc. found that 90% of the S&P 500 issued sustainability reports in 2019 compared to only 20% in 2011.

In 2020, the SEC Investor Advisory Committee weighed in with several conceptual recommendations that could be viewed as the first step to bringing this report under the auspices of the Commission. The committee’s review of sustainability reporting was grounded in its growing importance to investors. The committee pointed out that passivity with regard to these disclosures heightens the risk that either capital flows begin to favor overseas markets and/or U.S. markets fail to take the lead in shaping ESG reporting standards.

To counter these concerns, the committee made several recommendations.

Investors Require Reliable, Material ESG Information Upon Which to Base Investment and Voting Decisions: As companies vie for capital, inconsistent or inaccurate data hampers investment decisions. Currently, sustainability reporting tends to follow the guidelines outlined by three distinct reporting frameworks. The Global Reporting Initiative (GRI) first began publishing reporting standards in 1999 and maintains a warehouse of over 40,000 reports.

In 2017, the GRI began to move from a conceptual framework to reporting standards and over 51% of the S&P reporting companies utilize GRI guidelines. The Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB) was organized by investors to function much like the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) to bring a disciplined approach to sustainability reporting. SASB issues standards by industry that outline material topics and metrics to guide disclosure.

The third framework, Task Force on Climate-Related Financial Disclosures (TCFD), was organized by finance ministers and central bank governors to bring reliable and consistent disclosure to climate-related reporting. Currently, reporting companies are not required to adhere to any individual framework. However, a majority of S&P reporting companies utilize the GRI standards and 25% utilize or mention the SASB standards. Reporting entities are not necessarily relying exclusively upon one framework so duplication does occur.

Issuers Should Directly Provide Material Information to the Market Relating to ESG Issues Used by Investors to Make Investment and Voting Decisions: Because ESG reporting is not required, investors often rely upon third party sources to fill in gaps in available information. For example, 65% of S&P companies respond to the Carbon Disclosure Project questionnaire that scores and ranks respondents with regard to climate issues such as carbon emissions, water, waste and supply chain. However, the SEC notes that investors prefer and place greater reliance on direct disclosures by organizations.

To meet this demand, it is critical that companies report material information in a format consistent across an industrial sector since investors are using the information to allocate capital. The chairman of the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) has asserted that many sustainability reports “greenwash” the data to put themselves in the best possible light.

To bring credibility to the process, many reporting entities have begun to rely on third party reviews for external assurance. Surprisingly, engineering firms were the most common third-party reviewer providing assurance on greenhouse gas reporting. But accounting firms and other third-party consultants have also weighed in on sections of ESG reports.

One reporting entity has even provided an examination report from its auditor stating that no material errors were found in the data.

To date, only a very small number of reporting organizations have included the Sustainability Report with their 10-K even though other unaudited information such as MD&A are regularly included. And the SEC notes that concern over forward looking information should not hinder full disclosure since such information is also common in MD&A. Some registrants do file their Sustainability Report with the SEC as an 8-K Item 7.01 item under Regulation FD.

Finally, the SEC Notes That Requiring Material ESG Disclosure Will Level the Playing Field Between Issuers: Currently, small and mid-sized registrants are at a disadvantage with regard to disclosure due to resource constraints. Without the required reporting systems and necessary staff, these firms are not able to match the information provided by larger competitors. The SEC states that by standardizing the type of information and materiality of such data, the playing field could be made more level for all filers when competing for capital.

As the emphasis on factors beyond financial performance become more critical to investors and the financial sector as a whole, companies would be well served to take a fresh look at sustainability reporting and keep abreast of developing trends.

About the Author: Don Carpenter is clinical professor of accounting at Baylor University. Contact him at Don_Carpenter@baylor.edu.

 

  • The Future of CPA Licensing: TXCPA Members in Action at the State Capitol

    With the profession facing a talent shortage, legislative efforts are underway to introduce alternative pathways to licensure. Additionally, bills have been introduced to address CPA mobility and practicing accounting across state lines. TXCPA members took action at the Texas Capitol to address and emphasize the importance of these initiatives in strengthening the profession.
    View Article
  • CPE: Corporate Codes of Conduct - Similarities and Differences, and Implementation and Communication Strategies

    Codes of conduct serve as essential guidance for organizations, ensuring ethical behavior, regulatory compliance and corporate integrity. This article examines the significance of codes of conduct, highlighting examples from Fortune 500 companies. Effective implementation involves executive endorsement, ongoing communication and integration, and reinforcing accountability.
    View Article
  • Build on Our Momentum

    During TXCPA's 2025 Advocacy Day at the state Capitol, CPA professionals met with legislators to discuss proposed legislation on alternative CPA pathways and mobility. These efforts strengthened relationships with lawmakers, positioning CPAs as trusted advocates for the profession. The positive feedback from legislators reflects the impact of these advocacy efforts.
    View Article
  • Assessing AI From a Tax Perspective, Part 2

    In part 2 of a series, this article examines the risks and limitations of using AI in tax preparation. While AI tools like ChatGPT, Copilot, Perplexity, and TaxGPT can assist with tax research, their accuracy depends on precise prompts and professional oversight. Responses are often outdated, misleading or incorrect, posing risks to professionals who rely on them without verification.
    View Article
  • Understanding Sustainability Accounting Standards Board Standards

    The Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB) provides industry-specific guidelines for companies to report on ESG factors that impact financial performance. Companies use SASB metrics to enhance investor transparency and manage ESG risks. While SEC regulations on sustainability remain pending, over 3,000 companies worldwide have voluntarily adopted the standards to improve corporate performance.
    View Article
  • What’s Happening Around Texas - March-April 2025

    TXCPA chapters across Texas hosted various events to engage members and support future CPAs. TXCPA Dallas held a Coffee & Connections event, while TXCPA East Texas members inspired students at UT Tyler’s Beta Alpha Psi meeting. TXCPA Fort Worth welcomed new licensees at a luncheon and in San Antonio, members celebrated new iDEAL graduates and elected the 2025-2026 Officers and Directors.
    View Article
  • Navigating Timekeeping Compliance in Government Contracting

    Texas contractors receiving government funding must maintain rigorous accounting practices, particularly in timekeeping and labor distribution, to ensure they are adhering to federal regulations. CPAs and finance professionals play a crucial role in enforcing applicable standards. Mastering timekeeping is essential to help meet federal standards and uphold the integrity of taxpayer-funded projects.
    View Article
  • Spotlight on CPAs: Shilpa Boggram Sathyamurthy, CPA-Houston, CA

    Shilpa Boggram Sathyamurthy is an accounting profession leader with experience in both public and industry accounting. In this Spotlight on CPAs article, she discusses the differences in their focus, workload and learning opportunities. She also actively contributes to TXCPA through committee service, valuing collaboration and professional development.
    View Article
  • Do New SEC Disclosure Requirements for Share Repurchases Dilute Their Benefit?

    The SEC introduced new disclosure requirements for share repurchases, aiming to increase transparency. Under the updated rules, companies must now disclose daily repurchase data in quarterly reports. Companies must also disclose whether insiders traded in the four days before or after announcing a buyback. The rules do not specifically address accelerated share repurchase programs.
    View Article
  • Custom Reporting Solutions for ASC 842 Lease Accounting

    ASC 842 compliance remains challenging as organizations manage complex lease portfolios and multiple accounting systems. While standard software offers reporting features, many require custom solutions to integrate specific accounting attributes and enhance internal controls. Using a structured approach to developing custom reports can help improve efficiency and support the decision-making process.
    View Article
  • 2024-2025 Accounting Education Foundation Scholarship Recipients

    The TXCPA Accounting Education Foundation (AEF) awards scholarships to outstanding students, providing not only financial aid but also connections to a supportive community of experienced professionals. Congratulations to these exceptional students for their dedication and commitment to excellence!
    View Article
  • Take Note

    In this edition of Take Note: How to Get the Latest Updates on BOI Reporting; Safeguard What Matters Most; Accountants Confidential Assistance Network; Advocacy Day and Midyear Leadership Council Meeting; TXCPA Career Center; CGMA® Designation
    View Article
  • Classifieds

    The classified ad section features listings for practice owners looking to sell, professionals seeking firms to purchase and a variety of specialized services. Whether you're looking to expand, sell or explore niche opportunities, these classified ads can connect you to valuable business prospects and resources.
    View Article

CHAIR
Mohan Kuruvilla, Ph.D., CPA

PRESIDENT/CEO
Jodi Ann Ray, CAE, CCE, IOM

CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER
Melinda Bentley, CAE

EDITORIAL BOARD CHAIR
Jennifer Johnson, CPA

MANAGER, MARKETING AND COMMUNICATIONS
Peggy Foley
pfoley@tx.cpa

MANAGING EDITOR
DeLynn Deakins
ddeakins@tx.cpa

COLUMN EDITOR
Don Carpenter, MSAcc/CPA

DIGITAL MARKETING SPECIALIST
Wayne Hardin, CDMP, PCM®

CLASSIFIEDS
DeLynn Deakins

Texas Society of CPAs
14131 Midway Rd., Suite 850
Addison, TX 75001
972-687-8550
ddeakins@tx.cpa

 

Editorial Board
Derrick Bonyuet-Lee, CPA-Austin;
Aaron Borden, CPA-Dallas;
Don Carpenter, CPA-Central Texas;
Rhonda Fronk, CPA-Houston;
Aaron Harris, CPA-Dallas;
Baria Jaroudi, CPA-Houston;
Elle Kathryn Johnson, CPA-Houston;
Jennifer Johnson, CPA-Dallas;
Lucas LaChance, CPA-Dallas, CIA;
Nicholas Larson, CPA-Fort Worth;
Anne-Marie Lelkes, CPA-Corpus Christi;
Bryan Morgan, Jr, CPA-Austin;
Stephanie Morgan, CPA-East Texas;
Kamala Raghavan, CPA-Houston;
Amber Louise Rourke, CPA-Brazos Valley;
Shilpa Boggram Sathyamurthy, CPA-Houston, CA
Nikki Lee Shoemaker, CPA-East Texas, CGMA;
Natasha Winn, CPA-Houston.

CONTRIBUTORS
Melinda Bentley; Kenneth Besserman; Holly McCauley; Craig Nauta; Kari Owen; John Ross; Lani Shepherd; Patty Wyatt

 

Your TXCPA membership has not been renewed for 2025 -2026. Renew now.