SEC Proposes Controversial Rules Requiring Climate Related Disclosures

VIEW AS PDF

ACCOUNTING & AUDITING COLUMN

By Don Carpenter, MSAcc/CPA

It is rare to watch a newscast currently without at least one feature addressing climate change. International summits warn of the impacts of fossil fuel emissions on the environment and nations announce lofty goals for reducing these emissions over specific time horizons. Not surprisingly, both corporations and their investor pools have responded to these concerns.

In March, the SEC released proposed rules requiring reporting entities to include extensive disclosures regarding climate-related matters in registration statements and the annual Form 10-K. The proposed rules run to more than 500 pages.

Anticipating that these new requirements will not be welcomed in all quarters, the rationale and motivation for them encompasses the first 40 pages. In this introduction, the SEC highlights its obligations to protect the interests of investors and provide information that is meaningful in making investment decisions. They also point to recent developments in reporting frameworks and data standardization by the Task Force on Climate-Related Financial Disclosure and the Greenhouse Gas Protocol to support the timing of this proposal.

The proposed rules require new disclosures in the following categories:

1) The oversight and governance of climate-related risks by the registrant’s board and management;

2) How climate-related risks identified by the registrant have had or are likely to have a material impact on its business and financial statements over the short-, medium- and long-term;

3) How identified climate-related risks have affected or are likely to affect the registrant’s strategy, business model and outlook;

4) The processes used by the registrant to identify, assess and manage climate-related risks and whether any such processes are integrated into the overall risk management system;

5) Scope 1 and Scope 2 greenhouse emissions metrics, separately disclosed, by constituent greenhouse gasses and in aggregate in both absolute and intensity terms (to clarify, Scope 1 emissions are emissions that occur from sources controlled or owned by the organization; Scope 2 are indirect emissions associated with the purchase of energy used by the organization);

6) Scope 3 emissions if material or if the registrant has set GHG emissions reduction targets that include these emissions (Scope 3 include upstream emissions associated with purchased products, business travel, etc., as well as downstream activities such as emissions from the use of the company’s products or from further processing of such products);

7) The registrant’s climate-related targets and goals and any transition plans;

8) The impact of climate-related events (such as severe weather events or natural disasters) on specific financial statement line items.

Although not required, the disclosures can also include information related to any opportunities identified by the reporting entity arising from climate-related matters.

The first seven items listed above are required under an amendment to Reg. S-K. The additional disclosures will require a new section to the Form 10-K. However, referencing other sections of the report such as Risk Factors, MD&A or the Business Description within that new section is allowed to avoid redundancy.

The most difficult requirement under the amendment to Reg. S-K will likely be the disclosure of the Scope 1, Scope 2 and Scope 3 emissions. To further complicate the requirement, Large Accelerated Filers and Accelerated Filers will be required to include an attestation report with the Form 10-K and information about the attestation provider.

An initial transition period will allow for a limited attestation similar to the assurance currently provided on interim reports such as the Form 10-Q. This is followed by a second transition period requiring reasonable assurance defined as a level of assurance that the information provided is free from material misstatement.

The attestation report is required to address both the accuracy and consistency of the information reported.

This report may be provided by an independent subject matter expert such as engineering or environmental consultants who may be more qualified to address the topic than a registered public accounting firm.

Item 8 above will be required by an amendment to Reg. S-X. This information will be required to be included in a note to the company’s audited financial statements and is therefore required to be audited by the registrant’s accounting firm. In addition, it is included in the assessment of internal control over the integrity of financial reporting. The reporting under this requirement falls within three categories:

1) Financial statement impacts from both severe weather events or natural disasters, as well as the financial impacts of actions taken to reduce emissions or mitigate climate-related risks;

2) Expenditures related to the items listed in 1 separately aggregated between expenses and capitalized costs;

3) Extent to which estimates and assumptions affecting the financial statements are dependent upon climate-related risks.

The SEC emphasized that these disclosures are considered “filed” rather than “furnished” and are therefore subject to potential liability under the Exchange Act. A safe harbor provision is included specifically for Scope 3 emission reporting unless it can be demonstrated that the disclosure was made without a reasonable basis or in bad faith.

The disclosures will be phased in with Large Accelerated Filers, including all information except Scope 3 reporting in the first full year following adoption, with Scope 3 to follow one year later. Accelerated and Non-accelerated Filers follow one year later. And Smaller Reporting Companies begin in the third year with exemption from Scope 3 reporting entirely.

Given the nature of these proposed rules and the effort required to capture and report the information, it is anticipated that there will be significant comment and possibly even legal action in response. The SEC hopes to finalize the rules by the end of 2022, which would require Large Accelerated Filers to address the rules in their 2023 Form 10-K filed in 2024.

About the Author: Don Carpenter is clinical professor of accounting at Baylor University. Contact him at Don_Carpenter@baylor.edu.

 

  • TXCPA’s 2024 Rising Stars

    TXCPA's Rising Stars Program shines a spotlight on CPAs under 40 who are making a remarkable impact. These 18 honorees stand out for their leadership, commitment to the accounting profession and service to their communities. Join us in congratulating the 2024 Rising Stars!
    View Article
  • CPE: Update on Financial Reporting for Joint Venture Formation

    Joint ventures are powerful tools that allow companies to pool resources and technologies to innovate with new products, services and markets. Accounting Standards Update 2023-03 now fills a critical gap by setting new financial reporting standards specifically for joint venture formation. This article explores what finance professionals need to know about the guidance.
    View Article
  • What’s Happening Around Texas - November-December 2024

    Learn about some of the recent events and activities that happened around the state in the TXCPA chapters.
    View Article
  • Mitigating Medicare Mistakes: The CPA’s Role in Navigating IRMAA Challenges

    Navigating Medicare's Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount (IRMAA) can be challenging, especially for higher-income individuals who face additional premiums for Medicare Parts B and D. As CPAs, you play a crucial role in helping clients understand and plan for these potential extra costs, using your tax and financial expertise to guide them through Medicare’s complexities. This article explores strategies that can assist in minimizing IRMAA-related surprises.
    View Article
  • Pink-Collar Crime: An Interview with Kelly Paxton

    Kelly Paxton, a former U.S. Customs agent and expert in pink-collar crime, discusses the world of workplace embezzlement, which disproportionately involves women in lower to mid-level positions. Her insights emphasize that these are often crimes of opportunity rather than intent, making vigilance and ethical leadership essential in safeguarding against them.
    View Article
  • Celebrating Our 2024 Rising Stars!

    This issue of Today’s CPA is arguably one of the most anticipated issues of the year, where we celebrate the Rising Star Award winners! These young members are future leaders and innovators, shaping the future of TXCPA and inspiring the next generation of CPAs. They bring fresh ideas and excellence to our profession.
    View Article
  • Are Noncompete Agreements a Thing of the Past?

    In the world of business, protecting a competitive edge often means using noncompete agreements to keep valuable knowledge in-house. The FTC recently moved to limit noncompete agreements, banning most new ones as of September 2024, but this decision faces legal challenges. Until legal battles are resolved, businesses are expected to continue cautiously enforcing noncompete agreements.
    View Article
  • The 2024 Election and What it Means for Texas

    In the November 2024 election, Americans cast their votes for President, Congress, state offices and a host of local races. The 2024 election season felt especially long, marked by heated debates and high voter engagement. Here’s a summary of results and a look ahead to the key issues expected to shape the 2025 Texas legislative session.
    View Article
  • Take Note

    In this edition of Take Note: TXCPA's Career Center; Join the Key Persons Program; November is Accounting Opportunities Month and TXCPA Month of Service; Protect What Matters Most with Member Insurance; TXCPA’s Advocacy Day and Midyear Leadership Council Meeting on January 28-29; Accountants Confidential Assistance Network
    View Article
  • Classifieds

    The classified ad section offers a dynamic marketplace, featuring listings for practice owners looking to sell, professionals seeking firms to purchase and a variety of specialized services. Whether you're looking to expand, sell or explore niche opportunities, this section connects professionals with valuable business prospects and resources.
    View Article

CHAIR
Mohan Kuruvilla, Ph.D., CPA

PRESIDENT/CEO
Jodi Ann Ray, CAE, CCE, IOM

CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER
Melinda Bentley, CAE

EDITORIAL BOARD CHAIR
Jennifer Johnson, CPA

MANAGER, MARKETING AND COMMUNICATIONS
Peggy Foley
pfoley@tx.cpa

MANAGING EDITOR
DeLynn Deakins
ddeakins@tx.cpa

COLUMN EDITOR
Don Carpenter, MSAcc/CPA

DIGITAL MARKETING SPECIALIST
Wayne Hardin, CDMP, PCM®

CLASSIFIEDS
DeLynn Deakins

Texas Society of CPAs
14131 Midway Rd., Suite 850
Addison, TX 75001
972-687-8550
ddeakins@tx.cpa

 

Editorial Board
Derrick Bonyuet-Lee, CPA-Austin;
Aaron Borden, CPA-Dallas;
Don Carpenter, CPA-Central Texas;
Rhonda Fronk, CPA-Houston;
Aaron Harris, CPA-Dallas;
Baria Jaroudi, CPA-Houston;
Elle Kathryn Johnson, CPA-Houston;
Jennifer Johnson, CPA-Dallas;
Lucas LaChance, CPA-Dallas, CIA;
Nicholas Larson, CPA-Fort Worth;
Anne-Marie Lelkes, CPA-Corpus Christi;
Bryan Morgan, Jr, CPA-Austin;
Stephanie Morgan, CPA-East Texas;
Kamala Raghavan, CPA-Houston;
Amber Louise Rourke, CPA-Brazos Valley;
Nikki Lee Shoemaker, CPA-East Texas, CGMA;
Natasha Winn, CPA-Houston.

CONTRIBUTORS
Melinda Bentley; Kenneth Besserman; Holly McCauley; Shicoyia Morgan; Craig Nauta; Kari Owen; John Ross; Lani Shepherd; April Twaddle; Patty Wyatt

 

Your TXCPA membership has not been renewed for 2024 -2025. Renew now.